44 Comments
User's avatar
Simon Powell's avatar

Wow. Thanks so much Kell. I didn’t know about the letter that the hostages mother sent to him/his battalion (shock-positive news about Jews not featured in media).

I almost teared up reading that letter. What dignity and class. My lad is military age, and I can’t imagine that level of pain. I know you’ve got young ones too.

It really puts life in perspective. The question to those young people in the UK should have been “how would you feel if Britain were invaded and you HAD to fight”? Superfluous anyway, UK’s enemies are already there.

If only some people could be more open minded. They might realise Israeli society is the yardstick, not the world’s scapegoat.

Nice one mate.

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

Agree 100%. Funnily as an adjunct to the first poll they were then asked that very question. A large percentage said they don’t believe war solves anything. Yeah tell that to the people invading your country. I’m sure they will stop.

and yes the letter I think embodies Israeli spirit. Beautiful, empathetic but also pragmatic and real. A testament to their nation.

Expand full comment
Simon Powell's avatar

“Excuse me! Yes, you there, the one with the Kalashnikov. Regret to inform you, gosh this is a bit embarrassing, I don’t actually BELIEVE that what you’re doing is going to solve anything. Awfully sorry. Would you like a lift to the airport?” FFS 🤦‍♂️

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

I know right! Living in La La land, with queers for Palestine.

Expand full comment
Simon Powell's avatar

New question. “What would you do if an invading army was coming for your iPhone? And your mom was stuck at work?”

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

😂😂😂

Expand full comment
CurationCorner's avatar

Kelli again you have captured the essence of the Jewish Heart and Soul with this magnificent message from Iris Haim, thank you 💙 This article - https://jewdicious.substack.com/p/mitzvot-the-choice-to-do-good-could - may give further insight into the Jewish Psyche 💙 Am Yisroel Chai

Expand full comment
Eriko's avatar

I am also amazed by the courage and spirit of Yuval Raphael, October 7th survivor and Israel's Eurovision entry this year in Basel. Predictably, Pro-Palestine supporters have shown up en masse to intimidate her, one of them even performing a throat-slitting gesture which was caught on camera. I pray they have good security around the entire Israeli contingent and the other contestants make her feel welcome.

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

I’m sure she has more self belief than all those protesters added together. She is Israeli 🇮🇱

Expand full comment
Dan Solomon's avatar

The stereotypes perpetrated by antisemites about Jews being cowardly, venal, selfish, and immoral, tend to melt away after people actually get to know us and the best place to do this is Israel, where against all odds there is a corageous, generous, caring, and moral populace.

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

🤍🎗️☺️ 🇮🇱

Expand full comment
ForeignLocal's avatar

What a magic piece, my dear friend. Thanks wholeheartedly. I love it. So deeply. Am Yisrael Chai!

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

Thank you Al 🙏🏻🎗️

Expand full comment
Elliott Steinberg's avatar

Thanks for this. Yes, Israelis are the most resilient people on earth, with the biggest hearts. Careful about your wording though. Near the end, land “handed back” is not accurate. Jews bought back as much of their ancestral land as they could, transforming it into a haven. Any proposed sharing of land was based on that Jewish-owned development. Nothing was “given.” It was all earned through blood, sweat, and toil. Thank you for being an ally!

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

Noted. Thank you Elliot.

Expand full comment
Just plain Rivka's avatar

I saw Iris in a brief clip on Instagram when her son was still alive, but in captivity. She spoke to the son of the person who was recording the stories and she told him that he had beautiful blue eyes. I thought to myself, what kind of wonderful person can see the beauty in another human being as her son’s fate hangs in the balance? So I was not surprised by her amazing response to her son’s death. She has a way about her. A quiet joy, a generosity of spirit.

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

A woman to be admired. What grace!

Expand full comment
Just plain Rivka's avatar

Truly.

Expand full comment
kathy's avatar

Kelli, you are righteous and clear seeing and thinking. I applaud you and I’m so grateful to you. You’re a blessing to the world and — in times of my own need — to me. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

Thank you so much Kathy 🙏🏻

Expand full comment
Steve S's avatar

Kelli, have you been to Israel? You have the soul and heart to empathize and truly understand the people and the situation Jews face not only in Israel, but throughout the world. What a wonderful world this would be if all people, Jew, Christian, gentile, were like you.

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

I have not Steve. I desperately want to go. But funds don’t allow. 😢

Expand full comment
Nancy F's avatar

I loved reading this! Thank you for being so righteous.

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

Thank you Nancy 🎗️🤍

Expand full comment
Karen Sinclair's avatar

I agree with you totally Kelli. This is a brilliant summary of what I have also come to believe

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

Thank you Karen.

Expand full comment
Peter Samuel's avatar

Thanks Kelli, as always, again you have “hit the nail on the head” !!

Very helpful for people who have never been to Israel to understand.

Like Douglas Murray and Erick Stacklebeck said just after October 2023, the young Israeli “social media generation” out did themselves when they were required to stand up.

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

Yea. In his book he describes the young men and women of Israel as “magnificent” and I agree with him.

Expand full comment
Les Vitailles's avatar

Something elite US universities had already demonstrated with their Hamasshole encampments and micro-aggression trigger warnings.

This generation of Israelis is showing the world how a small country builds a great nation.

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

Yes, 100%!

Expand full comment
Shelah Horvitz's avatar

That was beautiful. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

Shelah 🤍🤍

Expand full comment
Richard Parker's avatar

Thank you for a passionate, truthful and beautiful essay. I hope it is widely read and shared.

Expand full comment
Kelli's avatar

Thank you so much Richard.

Expand full comment
Brenda Matsumura's avatar

One little tidbit, I saw Iris Haim in a rare interview after her hostage son broke free in middle of gun battle and mistakenly shot. She said a relative died in the Holocaust and she and her son had talked it over. He told her he would never be led " like a sheep to slaughter' and knew why he had made a wild break for it with 2 others. She was proud of her red haired boy for trying and held no ill will toward the young IDF Soldiers. Went on to say, " it was HAMAS' fault, for abducting him in the first place". Tremendous insight for a grieving mother.

Expand full comment